Better to have trolled and lost than... well you know the rest.

What makes me laugh is them saying to get a life... if life was really worth living they'd have never have needed to invent the internet.

It's a bit like Match of the Day, you just get to see the highlights, and some dribbling.

Don't Mercer come closest?  Troy were beautiful shirts - far more so, in many ways, than Makers.

Probably just me, but Sero never did drive me wild with excitement.  I'm probably talking arse here, but good Troy was possibly better than Mercer (?).  I've become (somewhat to Ms displeasure) a seeker of vintage Makers (and rather unusual ones, like the one from Michael I'm wearing now).  I've been disappointed on two occasions recently, though, when a. the shirt failed to arrive and b. the wrong shirt arrived.  The first was a nice subtle green gingham, which I particularly wanted.  The second I have passed onto a forum member, just as a second-best item. 
I'm still toying with the idea of a Mercer button-down Tattersall, with a third button and a locker loop.  Don't know whether I'll ever get around to it, though.

Just out of interest, where would you rank JS shirts amongst the above names, or would you?

The later labels breathe bullshit.