Never could get on with these, yet I know they have their devotees within the Ivy world. Having said that, I'm no fan of the repp tie, either, and only keep a couple of vintage American specimens for old times' sake. Never wear a suit nowadays, so minimalism is the word. Is black best? I once had an example in two contrasting colours: beige and, um, straw (?). John Simons does the look beautifully.
Navy, black several shades of brown (trigger alert) a rep style in navy and burgundy, reds, even a pink n orange 1980's number. I love them all but as you say don't get to wear them much at all sadly.
Repps are of no appeal to me whatsoever but a good knitted tie is a classic. I also love madras ties, but if I had to choose one type of tie to wear for the rest of my life: foulards. The king of ties.
And I have some killer foulards in my collection.
A pink and orange 1980s knit tie? The mind boggles.
Got quite a few knit ties. Mainly plain colours. Burgundy a favourite. Rarely wear them as I am retired.
One of my two ties, a slightly regimental-looking affair, came from 'Milton's Clothing Cupboard'. I like that. I see Milton as an Alan Arkin figure, harrassed by the women in his life, dreaming of Ann-Margret and a brief but joyful retirement in Miami.
I've got two boxes of knitted ties, most of them by Nick Bronson. As with everyone else, I do not get to wear them much these days. I got rid of all other types of tie a few years ago. I doubt I'll buy many more ties in future.
Of course, we live in times when our politicians and other lower-end types are happy to be seen wearing cheap-looking rubbish. And, for many of the men, no tie. Ah, I'm talking about the UK here, nowhere else. Yet, on my first day in a posh school, back in 2009, dressed in a Brooks suit, probably a repp tie and AE black wingtips, I looked out of place amidst the pullovers and beards. I wore a suit a time or two, sometimes with loafers, but often went in a grey Alan Paine cashmere v-neck and chinos or cords. My late father would not have dreamed of going tieless until he retired. Then it was all polo shirts, Levis and boat shoes.
Tie wearing seemed to end in my line of work in the early 90s. Working in an Architect's office a white Brooks shirt with knit tie was acceptable although many of the architects wore white shirts without ties. White shirts seemed a thing at the time because the leading architects (Foster, Rodgers et al) favoured them. The structural engineers and services engineers were always suited and booted.
I have little call for formal dress in work now and the end of working life is coming over the hill anyway. I’ve got plenty of repps, foulards and other traditional ties that will never see action again and I really should whittle them down to a handful for hatchings, matchings and dispatching purposes.
But I do like a knitted tie and wear one anytime I can conflate a justification for it. A knit tie seems to bridge the formal v informal gap quite nicely and any occasion that justifies wearing a tailored jacket, even if it’s just an old J Keydge, then I’m eyeing the tie box and wondering if I can get away with it!
One great advantage is they can be rolled up, stuck in a ziplock and kept in the glove compartment. This has saved me when I managed to get cigar ash all over my repp tie. Burning embers, etc. Serves me right for trying to multi-task.