Brooks get slated - the Hanging Pig ain't attractive - but the only shirt I ever bought from Regent Street (the only thing I ever bought from Regent Street) two days after they opened their doors still, after hundreds of washings, has a terrific roll.
Your mate Paddy viewed them as the ONLY shirt!
Last edited by Russell_Street (2010-08-08 13:31:20)
Last edited by 4F Hepcat (2010-08-08 11:05:15)
This is what I was trying to get across before about brooks. The london store is just awful because there is no choice.They seem to stock a pathetic amount of lines.
I think someone mentioned it was a concession.
my american made blue ocbds are superior to all else in roll and colour. That special iridescence.
Brooks Brothers definitely still makes a very good shirt, although in most US stores the all-cotton, must-irons are no longer stocked. Special-order only or available online.
Funny to think about LL Bean's shirts (and even Land's End) in the early 80's. They were excellent, came in a range of fabrics and were shameless copies of Brook's offerings. Now all one can find at Bean is the non-iron kind which are ok for what they are but not like the real deal. I also remember that endless quest for the perfect shade of pale or light-chambray blue. Brooks and Land's End had it, Bean never did, but they did a pale yellow that had a sunset luster hard to match.
Yep, shirts are a good place to start.
I have not tried the Andover shirts, but agree about Mercer and BB belonging in the A list compared to the others listed. I have tried Press. LE, and Gitman on the B list.
I agree with 4F about Mercer offering a greater variety of styles than BB if you are interested in other than the basics. Plus Mercer offers an unlied collar. However, BB does offer a lower price at least OTR as compared to Mercer.
J. Press were A list until the switch to Canadian manufacture and those new stiff collars - When was that? 2004?
Not Canada's fault. Press has to be in charge of what they do, no matter who actually does it for them.
I find Press shirts slightly 'limp', if you know what I mean. They're pleasant enough to wear and a flap pocket is a good place for sticking your bankroll, but there's no 'frisson'. Paddy and Jim were doubtless always ahead of the game but John Simons did promote Press a little bit, didn't he, even when the opinion there was that it had gone right off the boil. Be interesting if they opened up opposite Brooks, though, wouldn't it?
I was chatting to David Wilder about this a while back when he was coming to London, but that volcano got in the way...
Japan would need to decide.
Sometimes wondered if Paul Stuart would do well in London. Probably better in Milan or Rome.
Paul Stuart seems to do well in Tokyo, have seen it in quite a few shops for the "discerning" gent