Bear with me...
Once upon a short time ago different menswear shops had specific looks. The designer Italian, the English shooting, hunting fishing, the pastel preppy, the Cornish rugger-bugger.
You could, if the fancy took you, easily draw a picture of the typical customer for each store.
Take JS early days in Chiltern Street - Paraboots, proper knitwear, unstructured jackets, tweed overcoats, merino polo shirts. It all felt joined up and very different from what was generally available elsewhere.
Hopefully you're still with me...
Yesterday having started at JS I visited a number of different shops and they all felt very similar.
Trunk has Gitman button downs, shetlands, short tweed overcoats, watch caps and unstructured Vetra like jackets.
Over at Sunspel you have the unstructured cord suits, short tweed overcoats, Scottish knits, merino polos. They even sell traditional loafers and have a collab with Paraboot now
Drakes is an expensive version of JS. Games blazers are a cross between Vetra and Keydge. There's also plethora of button downs and shetlands. Plus Paraboots
I could go on and mention New and Lingwood, Polo, Cordings and William Crabtree.
So on a long train ride back to civilisation my thoughts were...
1. If I was going into menswear retail you now need the following: watch caps, fair isle knits, shawl collared cardigans, unstructured suits sold as separates, short tweed overcoats, merino polo shirts and some slightly brushed shetland sweaters.
2. Has JS influenced other stores? I know the guy from Drakes has been spotted there
3. Has Ivy simply become short hand for smart casual menswear. Post lockdown we don't bother so much.
4. Have I got too much spare time on my hands and need to get out more...
I think menswear has hit a stalling point to some degree, at least the mainstream stores / retailers.
As you say, there's a ubiquity to their collections, is this because JS has led the charge, or a signifier of a broader church of mens style through social media channels. If anyone of you are on Instagram and follow menswear, then if like me you find under the discover tab, everything is very samey – it's very much the looks above as well as workwear influenced, they could be look books for Clutch Cafe, Son of a Stag – add to the above YMC, Universal Works etc.
Unless you're going for the more outlandish stylings of Coleman Dingo (who I think looks superb, even if it's not my style or something I would attempt to carry off) et al, then you need to look for those little items and details that stand you out from the everyman, I leave that to each individual to decide upon.
Last edited by Tomiskinky (2024-12-05 11:39:41)
Yep I concur fully. I do think JS has influenced others. There is more choice broadly across a similar range. Also the trends that turn into books.
It's also one of the reasons I'm now a bit more pick and mix - the olive corduroy jacket from Cordings looks spot on with a great BD, Paraboots and drill jeans (family meal on Saturday).
It feels people can pick an era now - there's a revival of 20s-40s menswear online a lot and recreations of old menswear, some of it upper-middle class, some of it post Peaky Blinders working class.
Other than the gradually fading away, deliberately 'Mod' clothes, a touch of Ivy/Prep (I said the P word) have become an accepted smart casual as you say - often without the wearer knowing or caring. They might be wearing apron mocs without ever heard of Paraboot. As you say the Reiss, Oliver Spencer type menswear all have bits that look relevant. I didn't get to mention it before they had gone, but Joules had a run of Ivy looking 'blazers' (as they called them) with flap and patch pockets, tweed looking (but poly mix) etc recently. They are looking and copying from each other.
For example.... Barbour is back in the tailored jacket market through Next. Some very Ivy looking jackets but all in a slim fit and deliberately for young men.
How much difference is there to the casual purchaser between this I'll list below, my Cordings jacket, the years when JS has an olive cord jacket, ones available at Trunk or Drakes etc.
So from this:
https://www.next.co.uk/style/su023322/166639?gad_source=1&gclid=Cj0KCQiAu8W6BhC-ARIsACEQoDA1ULRlxj1eYrgTt2Bfn2KD1JArUXs-f7g4ZHPtezDxOBjuL_s2bjMaAgtwEALw_wcB&gclsrc=aw.ds#166639
to
https://www.drakes.com/products/olive-cotton-corduroy-games-blazer-mk-i-1?variant=43309264208085&country=GB¤cy=GBP&utm_medium=product_sync&utm_source=google&utm_content=sag_organic&utm_campaign=sag_organic&gad_source=1&gclid=Cj0KCQiAu8W6BhC-ARIsACEQoDCdnBbll8kaYyEFqUGdUkOUQgns2PqB69LKCnnzt20EbUgHtqtmzDIaAvSyEALw_wcB
As was said, it is the little details and differences that now matter. Which is why the pattern of fabric matters to me as much as a jacket's style. I really like the JS Ivy jackets but the brown new one is just too dull for me this time (also having an RL Ivy jacket in plain dark brown herringbone).
I'll reflect more on your post, it fits with what I see being sold online.
Last edited by An Unseen Scene (2024-12-05 15:36:24)
There are also such as Burrows snd Hare or Cad and the Dandy selling consistent styles with those mentioned too
Last edited by An Unseen Scene (2024-12-05 12:50:04)
Agree entirely. You can get brushed shetlands everywhere now (which is good) and natural shoulder jackets are everywhere (which are usually 'bad' if you want the 'right' look, but overall 'good' on the non-ivy obsessive). John Simons definitely influencing here, but it's definitely part of the wider resurgence of the look via Instagram. Ivy meets workwear algorithms.
Overall, it's probably a good thing, but it's all very, very expensive. More depressingly, people remain obsessed with labels, with Instagram feeling very soulless and hyper-consumptionist (I can't complain, I suppose, as I post lots of stuff on there (anonymously), but very rarely the (vintage, mostly-defunct) brands. All feels a bit modern ivy by numbers for the 21st century maybe. Like I say, it's good on the whole, but feels a bit superficial. Newton Street Vintage seems to be ahead of the trend, so I suspect lots of people will move onto a 90s armani kind of vibe (pleats, full cut trousers, big shoulders)...all very ugly to my mind, but I respect where it's going.
Agree the JS ivy jacket brown is underwhelming...totally different to their overcoat, actually, which is stunning. It doesn't take much to get the right black/brown herringbone mix.
I mean, this look - excluding the blue zip knit thing - is pure ivy. Wonderful: https://www.drakes.com/cdn/shop/articles/Carl_6_1_1080x.jpg?v=1704983673
But you're probably paying about £4000 for that outfit, which blows my mind, frankly...
Quote: Agree entirely. You can get brushed shetlands everywhere now (which is good) and natural shoulder jackets are everywhere (which are usually 'bad' if you want the 'right' look, but overall 'good' on the non-ivy obsessive). John Simons definitely influencing here, but it's definitely part of the wider resurgence of the look via Instagram. Ivy meets workwear algorithms.
The power of social media Colin. When I started wearing this stuff early 80's there were only 3 shops you could go to. One of the reasons I got into it was that it was not only smart but a bit unique. It seems almost everybody on IG is an expert on the subject these days. There also seems to be a fascination with mixing it up with ALD (Aime Leon Dore) which is one vowel away from being ALDI.
Proper old blokes shops seem to have disappeared. We found a great one in Tunbridge Wells. All Viyella shirts and tweed jackets, jockey underwear, branded socks. Not in a country way but in an old fella way. Would not want to buy anything in there but lovely to see they still exist. Few empty shops in Tunbridge Wells.
Here's another great one from Lewes. Sadly now closed. Lovely shop front too. Disabled parking in front .
Hugh Rae Ltd.
01273 473330
https://g.co/kgs/aVbvmyZ
Last edited by Kingston1an (2024-12-06 07:48:31)
Dunns was the classic old bloke chain.
Now reimagined on eBay as a brand signifying quality.
I often wonder where do the old fellers buy their clothes now?
Have things moved on enough that the current generation is either online or too old to buy their own clothes?
Meaning that there isn't any market for the shops we used to see.
I must say, I was kind of hoping I'd be able to age in Nottingham Council House parade flitting the ten feet between Austin Reed, Viyella and Jaeger, with the odd trip to M&S for essentials. It would of been absolutely lovely. There might of been better, but I wouldn't care. It would of been good enough, with nice people, who sometimes came from the back with a coffee for me (as they did at AR). Back then there was a Hipstore tempting over the way and Atomic design opposite selling all kinds of Midcentury/design items. Oh happy days. Thanks for nothing internet :-)
PS My Cordings Christmas card arrived today with the printed copy of Eric Clapton's signature. Mrs Unseen opened it and said 'really, that Eric Clapton?'.
Talking of which, a new Yardbirds documentary is on Sky and in his leaving them, there's no mention really of the style differences, more about his dedication to the blues only and their focus on 'having fun'. While shallow as most of these things are, it was a decent watch.
Last edited by An Unseen Scene (2024-12-06 09:02:12)
There is no market much for them. Oldies are wearing stuff they wore in their youth and sports wear. So aging rocker or JD sports. All the made to measure high street chains long gone.
Suit wearers eventually bought off the peg and packed suits in when they stopped working. You could probably tell the made to measure market from John Collier, Burton at the cheaper end to the more expensive brands at the other. Much of it manufactured at Hudson Road Mills in Leeds, regardless of the brand
Talking of old gentleman...
On Wednesday I was walking in St Christophers Place. I immediately noticed a chap walking slowly in front of me.
The most stunning herringbone sack, narrow dark navy jeans, red socks and LHS. As I walked past him I realised it was Graham Marsh.
Had to introduce myself and he was charm personified.
I hope when I get to his age I look half as good.
How wonderful!
Obviously switched out his cord sack jacket for the tweed, last time I saw him was at the Denim book launch with June and Tony.
Thankfully not in triple vintage denim to promote the book.